140 Broad St commercial building (Otty's / Mashtun Brewing)
Description
Two-story building for Otty's restaurant and Mashtun Brewing's taproom, recommended to Council with a traffic management plan and two-year GDP expiration.
Impact summary
Brings a year-round restaurant/taproom with up to roughly 80 patrons to a small downtown lot; neighbors' operating-hour concerns will be vetted at the PIP.
Applicant
- Name
- Pacific Property Holdings, LLC
- Address
- 140 Broad St, Lake Geneva, WISee this on the map
At a glance
- Hearings
- 3
- Public comments
- 0
- Total mentions
- 3
Last vote · Plan Commission
A recommendation, not a final decision. The council decides next.
Discussed at 1 meeting in the last 60 days; most recently Oct 19, 2026.
Meeting timeline (3)
Plan Commission - Oct 19, 2026
The final implementation plan to replace the old Bob's Beach Shack with a new commercial building — including lot-size and rear-setback waivers — was recommended for approval with six construction conditions.
Common Council - Aug 19, 2026
GDP approved for a two-story restaurant and taproom building downtown, including a requested zero-foot rear setback; details come later at the PIP stage.
Plan Commission - Jul 20, 2026
Demolish the old Bob's Beach Shack and build a two-story building for Otti's fish and chips and Mashtun Brewing's taproom; needs rear setback flexibility.
Related issues (1)
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda, when it's voted on and when its status changes, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for Lake Geneva
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.